Something slightly different today.
So the above image of some apparently liquid rock has been going around and along with it have been some rather bizarre claims.
One chap posts it on Facebook and asks …
Any stonemasons out there that can explain this 10,000 year old piece of liquefied granit?
Comments under that include …
Now that is bizarre..
I would love to know
believe in god and anything is possible.
Thats made by technology from another world
I’m lost for words
this high advanced technology for melting the granite in those ancient times… was surely brought by ET intelligence….
Somebody asked the guy posting it, “Where did you get this picture from?”, he replied …
I found it on a Russian site. I had to search their index for images. I found this image with the age. That is all. Hoping for an answer,
And then somebody rather sensibly asked ….
How do you know if 10,000 years old?
… but alas he did not respond to that. He did however explain in a later comment that the Russian site had claimed it was 10,000 years old.
Weird speculation continued. For example somebody posted some daft claim about Ancient High Tech/ Melt Stone With Light And Sound.
Eventually somebody had the right answer and so posted where it actually came from (I’ll hold fire on that for a moment, the reveal comes further down). I’ll simply make the observation that at least one person was able to do a google image search. It really is not hard to do, just grab the URL for any image, go to google, click “Image” and enter the URL, it will then give you links to anything where that same image is available. It is worth knowing how to do that so that when weird stuff like this pops up you can go check.
The poster eventually explained why he asked …
I found this image on a Russian archeological website. It wasn’t even displayed. I had to search their image index myself. It just litsted 10,000 years old C.A. Which I believe means carbon analysis. What (**persons name removed**) is presenting could certainly be the answer,
Er … no … there is no “could”. It most certainly is the precise source, that exact image and many other similar images come from the cited source along with the precise and wholly credible explanation.
What is truly weird is that even after the right answer is clearly posted, other commenters leap in with further ET speculation.
Debunking Weird Claims
Yes, the claims associated with this image do get a bit weird.
People see stuff they can’t explain, and so they respond with weird ideas. I’ll not bother linking to any of the actual weirdness out there associated with this, but instead will point you at an article within “Ancient American Explorer Magazine” that contains this precise image and discusses a claim about ancient stone softening plants …
For whatever reason fringe theorists and pseudoscientists have this belief that the megalithic sites in Peru and Bolivia used a rare plant that softens stone to mold them into place.It is said that there is a type of bird that lives deep in the Amazon basin that uses a plant to make its nests in stone. The plant supposedly has a chemical property that melts away or makes stone malleable.The stones at Sacsayhuaman look as if they were once clay molds and even show signs of vitrification on their outside layers.
There are however logical explanations that explain how the Inca and other groups in the area used round stones to shape these huge megaliths to where they look like the perfect fit.
In general, people do indeed cobble up weird stone softening claims when faced with examples of impressive stonework, but how such ancient artefacts were actually created is understood. As a bit of a hint, that subject-matter-expert explanation regarding ancient stone monuments tends to not involve aliens or mysterious stone melting plants.
The Reveal – It is Modern Artwork
The artefact, and many other similar items ,where created by Galician sculptor, Jose Manuel Castro Lopez. You can find him here on Facebook along with pictures of his artwork …
Here are some other examples of his work.
He is not melting stone, but as a sculptor he is carving it to shape. Here for examples are a series of shots of him working on a large piece …
I do wonder how he feels about his work being attributed to ancient aliens or magical stone softening plants.
I suspect he is highly amused.
10 thoughts on “Is liquid rock possible?”
Totally agree with you. The writer exhibits a pretentious attitude and false claims to proper deduction methods
melting the stones is not the hard part.. as your reference to the vitrification process demonstrates, if you melt granite, then let it cool, it does not turn back into granite. granite only forms when it is cooled under pressures higher than atmospheric pressures.
proving that someone did something, does not disprove that different things have been done by other people at other times.
your argument is logically invalid, a fallacy of the no-true-scotsman.
Oh, they could melt a stone. Friction from highfired ceramics gets the job done efficiently. More info at manofohm.Com .
So…… your saying he CARVED these rocks. I think the jokes on you. Look at the first photo in this link, it is not physically possible to make this from carving the rock. https://www.demilked.com/dynamic-plastic-organic-rocks-jose-manuel-castro-lopez/
I’d personally recommend hitting pause on playing the “I have no idea how he created this therefore magic/aliens/etc…” card.
What truly takes the biscuit here is that the link you provided identifies him as the sculptor.
Just because it can be sculpted to look a certain way doesn’t mean you have explained the stone, dummy
So let’s replay that. Identifying the name of the guy who sculpted the specific stone and showing you pictures of him actually doing similar sculptures leads you to the conclusion that it does not explain it. I’ve honestly no idea how that works.
All stone are molten at 1200°C
the question is whether they had the technology and the raw material to reach that temperature in sufficient quantities
Give these perfect logical explanations of how round diorite (since these are the claimed balls) were used to shape all ancient megaliths of multiple angles such as the walls of Sacsayhuaman. Better yet, as no one EVER has done replicate a 100ft section of that wall.
Better still, note the Inca never claimed to be the architects of the structures mainly attributed to them.
But setting this aside, if all that is too hard, show me not just a hypothesis, but one by someone who has done something similar not a 1/8th the size, soft talc replica, a granite chunk, of say 10 tonnes quarried from site to mountaintop, and cut and shaped and polished and lifted up to appropriate height.
I will wait, i imagine you will have this in a day or so so thanks in advance.
(Ps no i am not a liquid rock from plant juice advocate)