Professor Philip Alston, who is an expert on both extreme poverty and also human rights, has released a report today to the UN Human Rights Council on how Climate Change will make extreme poverty a lot worse. He has been especially appointed by them to focus on the issue.
What is Extreme Poverty?
Before a dive into the specifics of the report, it is perhaps best to begin with a quick definition of the term “Extreme Poverty”. It is not just about a lack of sufficient income, but also encompasses much more. Some still use the World Bank’s $1.25 a day definition, but that has problems. Extreme poverty not only involves a lack of income, but also includes a lack of access to basic services, and social exclusion.
If you use such Multidimensional metrics, then how many humans fall into the category of “Extreme Poverty”. Given it a go and have the quick guess.
According to UNDP’s Human Development Report 2014, over 2.2 billion people, more than 15 per cent of the world’s population, “are either near or living in multidimensional poverty”. That’s a mind blowing number.
What also naturally falls out of this are other things that will only add to the problem. Examples include lack access to education, health services or safe drinking water and basic sanitation.
What is also clear is that there is a relationship between extreme poverty and basic human rights. Deprive and entrap young children into servitude, deny them access to education, and what follows is a lifetime of extreme poverty. Addressing this issue is not about giving them money. If you don’t address the human rights violations, then nothing changes.
The latest report by Professor Alston, takes all of this to the next level and highlights that Climate Change is about to make all of this a lot worse.
Climate change and poverty
The full report published 25th June 2019 is available via this link.
Climate change will have the greatest impact on those living in poverty, but also threatens democracy and human rights.
Philip Alston, the UN Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty and human rights explains …
“Even if current targets are met, tens of millions will be impoverished, leading to widespread displacement and hunger, Climate change threatens to undo the last 50 years of progress in development, global health, and poverty reduction, It could push more than 120 million more people into poverty by 2030 and will have the most severe impact in poor countries, regions, and the places poor people live and work.”
Why will this happen?
Even the unrealistic best-case scenario of 1.5°C of warming by 2100 will see extreme temperatures in many regions and leave disadvantaged populations with food insecurity, lost incomes, and worse health. Many will have to choose between starvation and migration.
“Perversely, while people in poverty are responsible for just a fraction of global emissions, they will bear the brunt of climate change, and have the least capacity to protect themselves, We risk a ‘climate apartheid’ scenario where the wealthy pay to escape overheating, hunger, and conflict while the rest of the world is left to suffer.”
What are the Human Rights Implications?
Climate change has immense, but largely neglected, implications for human rights. The rights to life, food, housing, and water will be dramatically affected. But equally importantly will be the impact on democracy, as governments struggle to cope with the consequences and to persuade their people to accept the major social and economic transformations required. “In such a setting, civil and political rights will be highly vulnerable,” the Special Rapporteur said.
“Most human rights bodies have barely begun to grapple with what climate change portends for human rights, and it remains one on a long laundry list of ‘issues’, despite the extraordinarily short time to avoid catastrophic consequences, As a full-blown crisis that threatens the human rights of vast numbers of people bears down, the usual piecemeal, issue-by-issue human rights methodology is woefully insufficient.”
Lack of any Meaningful Action
Sombre speeches by government officials at regular conferences are not leading to meaningful action.
“States have marched past every scientific warning and threshold, and what was once considered catastrophic warming now seems like a best-case scenario, Even today, too many countries are taking short-sighted steps in the wrong direction.”
States are failing to meet even their current inadequate commitments to reduce carbon emissions and provide climate financing, while continuing to subsidise the fossil fuel industry with $5.2 trillion per year.
“Maintaining the current course is a recipe for economic catastrophe, Economic prosperity and environmental sustainability are fully compatible but require decoupling economic well-being and poverty reduction from fossil fuel emissions.”
What is required?
This transition will require robust policies at the local level to support displaced workers and ensure quality jobs.
“A robust social safety net will be the best response to the unavoidable harms that climate change will bring, This crisis should be a catalyst for states to fulfil long ignored and overlooked economic and social rights, including to social security and access to food, healthcare, shelter, and decent work.”
Although some have turned to the private sector for solutions, an overreliance on for-profit efforts would nearly guarantee massive human rights violations, with the wealthy catered to and the poorest left behind.
“If climate change is used to justify business-friendly policies and widespread privatisation, exploitation of natural resources and global warming may be accelerated rather than prevented.
“There is no shortage of alarm bells ringing over climate change, and an increase in biblical-level extreme weather events appear to be finally piercing through the noise, misinformation, and complacency, but these positive signs are no reason for contentment, A reckoning with the scale of the change that is needed is just the first step.”
One Last Thought
The border is not the problem, the border is the place where the symptoms of the problem manifest. You don’t change anything with a higher wall or a more secure border.