9 year old suspended for threatening to deploy magic

Texas_boy_suspended_after_bringing__ring_of_power__to_school_-_NY_Daily_NewsThis one left me scratching my head and wondering if we had received the full story.

Nine year old Aiden Steward (pictured above) has apparently been suspended from school in Texas for threatening to deploy magic. The UK’s Telegraph reports

The eager Middle Earth fan ended up suspended from Kermit Elementary School, after telling a classmate that he could make him disappear. 

“It sounded unbelievable,” the boy’s father, Jason Steward, told the New York Daily News.

“Kids act out movies that they see. When I watched Superman as a kid, I went outside and tried to fly.”

“I assure you my son lacks the magical powers necessary to threaten his friend’s existence,” Steward later wrote in an email to the school.

“If he did, I’m sure he’d bring him right back.”

So I can only step back, pause and wonder what the school was thinking. Kids play and as they do so, they will often immerse themselves in a fantasy. It is in this context that the school now appears to have stepped in and started to police this!! … that is quite frankly absurd.

Could it get any more bizarre?

Apparently yes …

According to the Daily News, Aiden has been suspended twice before: once for referring to a classmate as “black”, and once for bringing his favourite book to school, a children’s encyclopedia called The Big Book of Knowledge.

“He loves that book. They were studying the solar system and he took it to school. He thought his teacher would be impressed,” the boy’s father said. He went on to explain that, after the teacher discovered that the children’s encyclopedia contained a section on pregnancy, including an illustration of a pregnant woman, bringing it in was deemed a suspension-worthy offence.

So he brings an encyclopaedia to school and that merits a suspension because it explains human reproduction with illustrations. Now if he had brought in some porn, I’d get it, but this is not that, and instead appears to be an attempt to stifle curiosity, knowledge and dreaming.

Yes, the school name helps to mock all this … a school in Texas (where else could something like this happen), named Kermit Elementary School, is apparently run by a bunch of muppets (oh come on now, how could anybody resist making that observation).

OK, so we do not know all the facts, but let’s assume the absolute worst, let’s suppose he had indeed been screaming threats and racial slurs at another kid, and had been posting porn on the walls. If even that was true, suspension is not the correct answer, but rather this is the right time to sit him down and talk all this though.

Is every school in Texas like this?

Nope, and so if all this is truly factual (I do harbour doubts about that), then what I’d suggest we really have here is a big bold neon sign advising parents that it is time to go find another school.

Being curious, I googled the school and found some rather bizarre reviews … no wait, take those with a huge grain of salt, they are all recent and are clearly responses to this media story.

Exercise doubt and suspend judgement

I would recommend that we should perhaps treat the entire story with a pinch of salt, because what we do not have is full disclosure, but rather only one side. The school has, quite rightly, refused to comment at all, and so we simply do not know what really happened.

I have briefly reviewed their student code of conduct and can find nothing abnormal about it in any way at all, and that is why doubt is indeed an appropriate response.

1 thought on “9 year old suspended for threatening to deploy magic”

  1. I get the impression that the kid is being targeted, and the administration is just looking for little things to get him on (perhaps his parents are going against the grain and getting under their skin). It also makes me wonder if the school would be as equally responsive if a child raised Christian told a non-believing child she was going to hell.


Leave a Reply